Every so often, a cover version comes along that does more than just pay tribute to a beloved song—it completely redefines it. It’s no longer just a remix or a straightforward rendition; it becomes an artistic statement that invites us to see the song—and perhaps even ourselves—in a new light. That’s precisely what happened when a young singer named Drew Ryniewicz took the stage and performed Justin Bieber’s hit “Baby.” Her version wasn’t just a cover; it was a whole new take that left the judges saying, “You know what? I like your version better.” Actually, some of them went even further, openly admitting they preferred her interpretation over the original. That’s rare, and it speaks volumes about how powerful reimagining can be.
Let’s rewind to 2011, when a 14-year-old Drew auditioned on The X Factor. From the moment she stepped onto that stage, it was clear she was daring to be different. She chose to cover Bieber’s “Baby,” a song that by then was already an iconic pop hit. But Drew didn’t simply replicate the original. Instead, she dramatically transformed it into a slow, soulful, and emotionally vulnerable version. Her voice carried a tenderness that contrasted with the song’s dance-pop vibe, and she stripped it down to its core—nothing but her voice and a subtle instrumental background. Watching her, it was like witnessing a different story unfold—a story of raw human emotion, honesty, and artistic bravery.
That kind of reinterpretation was risky. Everyone knew “Baby” as an upbeat, energetic anthem for a young pop star. To so radically reimagine it was a gamble. Would the audience accept it? Would the judges like it? But sometimes, in art, taking risks is what makes all the difference. And Drew’s version proved just that. Her audacity to change the familiar into something deeply personal and emotional set her apart from the crowd and made her performance unforgettable.
When the judges delivered their feedback, the reactions were just as remarkable as the performance itself. Nicole Scherzinger, who was a big Justin Bieber fan, paused with a contemplative look on her face—and then surprised everyone by saying she actually preferred Drew’s version to the original. Simon Cowell, usually the most critical, nodded approvingly and praised her for being able to “make it hers.” Even L.A. Reid, who had collaborated with Bieber earlier in his career and was probably familiar with all the ins and outs of his sound, declared that Drew’s performance was “soulful and believable.” Paula Abdul summed up the judges’ collective awe by calling her performance “commendable, original, daring, and bold.” And the entire panel seemed completely won over by her bravery, her raw emotion, and her incredible talent. It was a clear message that sometimes, a reinterpretation can evoke more emotion and connect more deeply than the original version.
So, what was it that made Drew’s take on “Baby” land so strongly with the judges? For starters, it was her ability to make the song feel authentic and heartfelt. She completely stripped away the upbeat production, shining a spotlight on her raw vocal vulnerability. Instead of trying to mimic Bieber’s style, she reimagined the song through her own voice, her own feelings. That sense of artistic ownership—performing not just to prove she could sing, but to express something personal—resonated with everyone watching. And her choice to give it a slow, soulful spin created a contrast effect; hearing such a familiar song in a completely new arrangement made listeners re-listen and rethink their expectations.
What really struck people was her courage and authenticity. It takes guts to stand in front of judges and a live audience and say, “Here’s my version,” especially with a song as iconic as “Baby.” Drew’s fearless approach and the sincerity she put into her performance made her stand out. She was not just singing; she was storytelling, sharing her interpretation of the song’s meaning through her own lens. That kind of honesty is rare—especially in a high-pressure contest.
This is why, beyond just a story about one young singer versus a pop star, it’s a reminder that music is a living, breathing art form. Covers aren’t just about copying what came before; they’re conversations. When an artist dares to reinterpret a song, they invite us—listeners and judges alike—to re-experience something we thought we knew. It’s a chance to see familiar melodies in a new mood, a new light, and sometimes, that fresh perspective can be even more powerful than the original.
So, I ask you—what’s your take? Do you prefer faithful covers that stay true to the original, or do you find yourself more drawn to daring reinventions that push the boundaries of what a song can be? Have you ever heard a cover that totally blew you away, making you think, “Wow, that’s better than the original”? If you’re interested, I’d love to share some more favorites, including videos, comparisons,
What do you think about SINGLE DAD Singing style? Share your thoughts in comment! ✨
